Summer 2005 Contest
Summer 2005 Contest Analysis Crew
creativename (33) | Board List | Topic List
| Tag TopicThis Topic has been marked closed. No additional messages may be posted.
Page 1 of 10 | Next
Page
| Last
Page
From: Master Moltar
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:29:40 PM | Message Detail
| #001
Alright Board 8, it’s Contest time again, and I know you all are
excited. I am too, so excited in fact, I organized a Crew of me and 6
(yep, 6; we’re even bigger now!) other users, whom you know and love,
to analyze every match in this Contest because we love it so much. You
might remember this from the Spring 2004 Contest, Summer 2004 Contest,
and Spring 2005 Contest, and now we are back to analyze this beauty of
a Contest right here.
Now unless you’ve been living under a rock for the past years, or are a new user, I’ll tell you the basic premise of this. Our job, as the Crew, is to analyze and predict each match that takes place in the Summer 2005 bracket. During these analyses, we tell you what we think is going to occur, and why we think that. So yeah, we’re basically here to tell you why your picks are either right, wrong, or just plain stupid. But you didn’t enter this topic for me to explain stuff; you want the write-ups! Well…scroll down a little for those, because first we have introductions! Here, you get to find out a little about the Crew and our expectations for the Contest. Happy reading, and I hope you enjoy our write-ups as much as we did writing them…..actually, I just hope you enjoy our work. =D
Moltar - Three words, readers. This bracket owns! It’s the best way I can say it. It might have taken CJayC a lot longer than usual to get the bracket up, but it was sure worth the way. Every day, some match is being discussed. Upsets could happen all over the place. Brackets are a lot more diverse, arguments are a lot more fierce, and lots of fun is left to be had. This Contest should be one of, if not, the best Contest we’ve ever had. Be sure to expect the unexpected…like Shadow getting snubbed…Shadow didn’t deserve that…Shadow deserves to own in this bracket...Shadow… .Shadow?!!?…SHADOOOOOW!!!</whining>
Ulti - After two contests that were absolutely dull, the most recent of which ended around two months ago, CJayC decided to shock the hell out of us with the Summer 2005 bracket. Not only did he take extra time to make the bracket as good as possibly could (it's quite clear he used the extrapolated stats), but he made it 8 divisions of 8 and got rid of company caps. This essentially gets rid of the standard crap that you see with 9-16 seeds while allowing the entire bracket to be stronger overall. And while some fodder still got in, most of the fodder are board favorites that we wanted to see get creamed, anyway. What this leaves us with is a fun, hard to call bracket that can only be outdone by 2002/2003.
So without further ado, let's get right into the matches themselves.
Soul - Hello Board 8. I'm XxSoulxX. This is my second contest doing this little project. In the Spring Contest, I finished tied for first, which was pretty cool. Of course, that was only for 32 matches. Now, I've been invited to participate in the big contest. And man, what a contest at that. With lots of upset possibilities and a whole slew of new entrants, this contest looks to be the best Summer Contest yet. Only one problem though: This contest lacks Christian. No biggie, I'm sure he was ranked 65th and was therefore snubbed for Agent 47... Anyway, on to the predictions!
Outback - Thumbs up. The bracket's good. Keeps us interested, gives us some matches we've been waiting to see (namely Sonic/Mega Man), and makes a tournament with an unpredictable winner. However, I have one main complaint. Too many obscure characters; not enough classics. Why is Agent 47 in over Fox McCloud? Why is Yuri Hyuga in over Ken Masters? Yes, these 2 snubs I listed are characters I like. There are other snubs I didn't mention. But honestly, are Yuri Hyuga and Agent 47 making this contest any more predictable or interesting? I think not, and next time, Ceej, please look past the top 64 and try to make a more interesting bracket with possibly the top 70, 80, or 100. With all that said, I think this is the best bracket yet, and look forward to the contest.
Now unless you’ve been living under a rock for the past years, or are a new user, I’ll tell you the basic premise of this. Our job, as the Crew, is to analyze and predict each match that takes place in the Summer 2005 bracket. During these analyses, we tell you what we think is going to occur, and why we think that. So yeah, we’re basically here to tell you why your picks are either right, wrong, or just plain stupid. But you didn’t enter this topic for me to explain stuff; you want the write-ups! Well…scroll down a little for those, because first we have introductions! Here, you get to find out a little about the Crew and our expectations for the Contest. Happy reading, and I hope you enjoy our write-ups as much as we did writing them…..actually, I just hope you enjoy our work. =D
Moltar - Three words, readers. This bracket owns! It’s the best way I can say it. It might have taken CJayC a lot longer than usual to get the bracket up, but it was sure worth the way. Every day, some match is being discussed. Upsets could happen all over the place. Brackets are a lot more diverse, arguments are a lot more fierce, and lots of fun is left to be had. This Contest should be one of, if not, the best Contest we’ve ever had. Be sure to expect the unexpected…like Shadow getting snubbed…Shadow didn’t deserve that…Shadow deserves to own in this bracket...Shadow… .Shadow?!!?…SHADOOOOOW!!!</whining>
Ulti - After two contests that were absolutely dull, the most recent of which ended around two months ago, CJayC decided to shock the hell out of us with the Summer 2005 bracket. Not only did he take extra time to make the bracket as good as possibly could (it's quite clear he used the extrapolated stats), but he made it 8 divisions of 8 and got rid of company caps. This essentially gets rid of the standard crap that you see with 9-16 seeds while allowing the entire bracket to be stronger overall. And while some fodder still got in, most of the fodder are board favorites that we wanted to see get creamed, anyway. What this leaves us with is a fun, hard to call bracket that can only be outdone by 2002/2003.
So without further ado, let's get right into the matches themselves.
Soul - Hello Board 8. I'm XxSoulxX. This is my second contest doing this little project. In the Spring Contest, I finished tied for first, which was pretty cool. Of course, that was only for 32 matches. Now, I've been invited to participate in the big contest. And man, what a contest at that. With lots of upset possibilities and a whole slew of new entrants, this contest looks to be the best Summer Contest yet. Only one problem though: This contest lacks Christian. No biggie, I'm sure he was ranked 65th and was therefore snubbed for Agent 47... Anyway, on to the predictions!
Outback - Thumbs up. The bracket's good. Keeps us interested, gives us some matches we've been waiting to see (namely Sonic/Mega Man), and makes a tournament with an unpredictable winner. However, I have one main complaint. Too many obscure characters; not enough classics. Why is Agent 47 in over Fox McCloud? Why is Yuri Hyuga in over Ken Masters? Yes, these 2 snubs I listed are characters I like. There are other snubs I didn't mention. But honestly, are Yuri Hyuga and Agent 47 making this contest any more predictable or interesting? I think not, and next time, Ceej, please look past the top 64 and try to make a more interesting bracket with possibly the top 70, 80, or 100. With all that said, I think this is the best bracket yet, and look forward to the contest.
From: Master Moltar
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:30:05 PM | Message Detail
| #002
Inviso - After a four way tie for first place, I’m back, in the
flesh and in the fur to analyze the summer contest this time around.
Let’s just see the boys try to keep up this time. =^_^=
Inviso’s Thoughts on the Bracket: In my opinion, there are way too many RPG characters in this bracket…and most of them are going out round one. If you’re going to have fodder, at least have it from different genres. I realize this is Gamefaqs, but characters like Yuri and Geno stand no chance of winning any match, because unless you’re from a Square RPG, you aren’t going anywhere except past a few weak fodder characters yourself. The seeding sucks too, with Dante and Kirby as ones while Crono is a two AGAIN…and Dante will go out second round, as will Kirby. A lot of characters that have proven themselves to be strong got snubbed, like Aeris, Shadow, Liquid Snake, and to a lesser extent, Tails, while Manny Calavera and Agent 47 make it in. All in all, I think the only reason board 8 likes the bracket so much is because there are so many RPG characters, and because it’s difficult to predict, which kinda sucks, because now chances are even smaller of winning the prize. Also, Link, Cloud and Sephiroth shouldn’t have been moved, because they can really take out the trash like CATS, and should do so this year.
Tnote - Well, this is the fourth contest I have been around for, and easily the one I am most excited about. For the first time in my tenure, the finals are not 100% predictable for those of us who follow the contest with anything more than a passive approach. Everyone knew CT/FFVII, Link/Cloud and Sephiroth/Ganondorf were going to be our title matches. And with the exception of Link/Cloud, even the champion was fairly evident in the above matches. This year, with the exclusion of Clinkeroth from the field of 64, the champion truly is unknown. Crono, Samus and Mario are all logical choices for the SC2K5 crown,
and an argument could be made for Mega Man potentially making a run to the tournament of champions.
While I admit the bracket is rather Square-heavy, to me that is not a bad thing, because even though Zidane is going to get beat like a red-headed stepchild by Crono, his inclusion means the exclusion of the Tanners, Guybrushs and Hazukis. And anytime we can exclude pirates and cat lovers, that is a good thing. Some uber-fodder remains, but as a whole, this 64 character bracket, coupled with the addition of a tournament of champions, makes this the most exciting and unpredictable bracket in my 2.5 years at GameFAQs.
Vlado - And so, the time has come for the fourth GameFAQs Character Battle. After an absolutely boring Villain Contest, CJay obviously decided to work hard towards making this an exciting one and I think he'll be successful. Cloud, Link and Sephiroth being out of the main bracket, it makes it much less predictable and it opens the path for a new champion. Who will it be? Crono? Samus? Someone else? We'll see. A first glance at the bracket shows many interesting matches, with Mario vs. Samus taking the cake. Will Mario win and eliminate Crono's main threat for the title? Or will Samus make it and move on to face The Silent Hero? Who will the Nintendo fans support? This seems to be the main question of the contest, even more important than who would be crowned as the new champion.
As for the aftermath, the short Tournament of Champions, all that I can say is that whoever wins the main bracket will lose to Sephiroth. As for Cloud vs. Link, we know that the winner will win the whole thing. But who will win between them? Advent Children will already be out and I don't think this one is as easy to predict as it may look. One thing's for sure and it's that we're in for another summer of fun, thanks to our beloved contest, the most sacred GameFAQs tradition.
Inviso’s Thoughts on the Bracket: In my opinion, there are way too many RPG characters in this bracket…and most of them are going out round one. If you’re going to have fodder, at least have it from different genres. I realize this is Gamefaqs, but characters like Yuri and Geno stand no chance of winning any match, because unless you’re from a Square RPG, you aren’t going anywhere except past a few weak fodder characters yourself. The seeding sucks too, with Dante and Kirby as ones while Crono is a two AGAIN…and Dante will go out second round, as will Kirby. A lot of characters that have proven themselves to be strong got snubbed, like Aeris, Shadow, Liquid Snake, and to a lesser extent, Tails, while Manny Calavera and Agent 47 make it in. All in all, I think the only reason board 8 likes the bracket so much is because there are so many RPG characters, and because it’s difficult to predict, which kinda sucks, because now chances are even smaller of winning the prize. Also, Link, Cloud and Sephiroth shouldn’t have been moved, because they can really take out the trash like CATS, and should do so this year.
Tnote - Well, this is the fourth contest I have been around for, and easily the one I am most excited about. For the first time in my tenure, the finals are not 100% predictable for those of us who follow the contest with anything more than a passive approach. Everyone knew CT/FFVII, Link/Cloud and Sephiroth/Ganondorf were going to be our title matches. And with the exception of Link/Cloud, even the champion was fairly evident in the above matches. This year, with the exclusion of Clinkeroth from the field of 64, the champion truly is unknown. Crono, Samus and Mario are all logical choices for the SC2K5 crown,
and an argument could be made for Mega Man potentially making a run to the tournament of champions.
While I admit the bracket is rather Square-heavy, to me that is not a bad thing, because even though Zidane is going to get beat like a red-headed stepchild by Crono, his inclusion means the exclusion of the Tanners, Guybrushs and Hazukis. And anytime we can exclude pirates and cat lovers, that is a good thing. Some uber-fodder remains, but as a whole, this 64 character bracket, coupled with the addition of a tournament of champions, makes this the most exciting and unpredictable bracket in my 2.5 years at GameFAQs.
Vlado - And so, the time has come for the fourth GameFAQs Character Battle. After an absolutely boring Villain Contest, CJay obviously decided to work hard towards making this an exciting one and I think he'll be successful. Cloud, Link and Sephiroth being out of the main bracket, it makes it much less predictable and it opens the path for a new champion. Who will it be? Crono? Samus? Someone else? We'll see. A first glance at the bracket shows many interesting matches, with Mario vs. Samus taking the cake. Will Mario win and eliminate Crono's main threat for the title? Or will Samus make it and move on to face The Silent Hero? Who will the Nintendo fans support? This seems to be the main question of the contest, even more important than who would be crowned as the new champion.
As for the aftermath, the short Tournament of Champions, all that I can say is that whoever wins the main bracket will lose to Sephiroth. As for Cloud vs. Link, we know that the winner will win the whole thing. But who will win between them? Advent Children will already be out and I don't think this one is as easy to predict as it may look. One thing's for sure and it's that we're in for another summer of fun, thanks to our beloved contest, the most sacred GameFAQs tradition.
From: Delirium Trigger
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:30:37 PM | Message Detail
| #003
LOL BLACK MAN
---
Explicit Content, having fun, not being warned.
Cheer Up Emo Kids.
---
Explicit Content, having fun, not being warned.
Cheer Up Emo Kids.
From: Master Moltar
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:31:11 PM | Message Detail
| #004
And that concludes the Introductions. Except the Mario/Joanna analyses posted sometime around bracket lockdown.
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
SC2K5: Samus is going all the way!
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
SC2K5: Samus is going all the way!
From: Slowflake
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:31:34 PM | Message Detail
| #005
Shadow didn%u2019t deserve that%u2026Shadow deserves to own in this
bracket...Shadow%u2026 .Shadow?!!?%u2026SHADOOOOOW!!!</whining>
Die.
---
SC2K5 bracket: Samus over Snake, Crono over Megaman, Samus over Crono; Link over Sephiroth
Die.
---
SC2K5 bracket: Samus over Snake, Crono over Megaman, Samus over Crono; Link over Sephiroth
From: Delirium Trigger
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:31:59 PM | Message Detail
| #006
Good thing I introduced you, no one would have known who to throw things at.
---
Explicit Content, having fun, not being warned.
Cheer Up Emo Kids.
---
Explicit Content, having fun, not being warned.
Cheer Up Emo Kids.
From: Slowflake
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:31:59 PM | Message Detail
| #007
And no, I'm not fixing this. Shadow isn't even worth it.
---
SC2K5 bracket: Samus over Snake, Crono over Megaman, Samus over Crono; Link over Sephiroth
---
SC2K5 bracket: Samus over Snake, Crono over Megaman, Samus over Crono; Link over Sephiroth
From: Mr Lasastryke
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:32:15 PM | Message Detail
| #008
teh taggage
---
Cool tracks: Bob Dylan - Hurricane / Aphex Twin - Window licker / Radiohead - Idioteque
---
Cool tracks: Bob Dylan - Hurricane / Aphex Twin - Window licker / Radiohead - Idioteque
From: Grengosaurus
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:33:28 PM | Message Detail
| #009
That's a whole lot o' analyzers.
---
Eating peasants like popcorn
Common, Talib Kweli, Mos Def, De La Soul, Kanye West = Kings of Hip Hop
---
Eating peasants like popcorn
Common, Talib Kweli, Mos Def, De La Soul, Kanye West = Kings of Hip Hop
From: ExThaNemesis
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:34:02 PM | Message Detail
| #010
Hey Slowflake. Shadow won a match in 2003! BURN
From: Tai
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:35:02 PM | Message Detail
| #011
Tag.
Good luck.
---
PETITION: Ability to preview contests to moderators before posting it. http://boards.gamefaqs.com/gfaqs/genmessage.php?board=7&topic=19643565 (198 Signs!)
Good luck.
---
PETITION: Ability to preview contests to moderators before posting it. http://boards.gamefaqs.com/gfaqs/genmessage.php?board=7&topic=19643565 (198 Signs!)
From: Slowflake
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:36:02 PM | Message Detail
| #012
*tombstones ExTha*
---
SC2K5 bracket: Samus over Snake, Crono over Megaman, Samus over Crono; Link over Sephiroth
---
SC2K5 bracket: Samus over Snake, Crono over Megaman, Samus over Crono; Link over Sephiroth
From: ExThaNemesis
| Posted: 7/18/2005 1:36:34 PM | Message Detail
| #013
*rests in peace*
From: Heroic Viktor
| Posted: 7/18/2005 4:17:45 PM | Message Detail
| #014
guess we'll tag this... nothin' like reading your own writing =)
---
RIP: Tnote827 - 4/4/2005
Sp2k5 - 77/80 (stupid Master Hand)
---
RIP: Tnote827 - 4/4/2005
Sp2k5 - 77/80 (stupid Master Hand)
From: Suprak the Stud
| Posted: 7/18/2005 4:21:54 PM | Message Detail
| #015
Tag
From: Opiate109
| Posted: 7/18/2005 4:22:13 PM | Message Detail
| #016
Tag.
---
Wheels within wheels, in a spiral array
A pattern so grand and complex.
---
Wheels within wheels, in a spiral array
A pattern so grand and complex.
From: UltimaterializerX
| Posted: 7/18/2005 4:24:01 PM | Message Detail
| #017
You took out what I had in parenthesis, you bastard :(
~*ST*~
---
Winner of the Spring 2004 "Best. Game. Ever." Contest
"If my fate is to be destroyed... I must simply laugh!" -Magus
~*ST*~
---
Winner of the Spring 2004 "Best. Game. Ever." Contest
"If my fate is to be destroyed... I must simply laugh!" -Magus
From: Draco1214
| Posted: 7/18/2005 4:25:38 PM | Message Detail
| #018
tag
---
Summer 2005 Contest - 0/0 points
Current Match Prediction: Mario vs. Joanna Dark
---
Summer 2005 Contest - 0/0 points
Current Match Prediction: Mario vs. Joanna Dark
From: XxSoulxX
| Posted: 7/18/2005 4:45:47 PM | Message Detail
| #019
Wow, 7 predictors now? This is going to be tough.
---
"ertyu is actually a language. For example, 'dum' is ertyunese for 'godly'." - Topaz Kitsune
*Waiting for Guru winner's sig*
---
"ertyu is actually a language. For example, 'dum' is ertyunese for 'godly'." - Topaz Kitsune
*Waiting for Guru winner's sig*
From: The Doppleganger
| Posted: 7/18/2005 4:51:06 PM | Message Detail
| #020
Tag
---
WWEGSB Hardcore Legend Masa
*Is now in need of a sig
---
WWEGSB Hardcore Legend Masa
*Is now in need of a sig
From: Phorever A Phan
| Posted: 7/18/2005 5:05:17 PM | Message Detail
| #021
tiggity-tag
---
-A Phan
"Set your gearshift for the high gear of your Soul!!"
---
-A Phan
"Set your gearshift for the high gear of your Soul!!"
From: Sesshomaru Purified
| Posted: 7/18/2005 5:05:51 PM | Message Detail
| #022
taggy
---
AC/DC
---
AC/DC
From: Doctor Clarinet
| Posted: 7/18/2005 5:09:01 PM | Message Detail
| #023
These are always fun...
---
"If I had a dollar for every time Spongebob annoyed me, I'd have one dollar. He's just one unceasing continuity of annoyingness." -my friend
---
"If I had a dollar for every time Spongebob annoyed me, I'd have one dollar. He's just one unceasing continuity of annoyingness." -my friend
From: Buzzup
| Posted: 7/18/2005 5:18:32 PM | Message Detail
| #024
Tag'd
---
As much as I want to put something original about the Guru Contest here, I can't, because Yoblazer owned me way too hard.
---
As much as I want to put something original about the Guru Contest here, I can't, because Yoblazer owned me way too hard.
From: Master Moltar
| Posted: 7/18/2005 8:17:24 PM | Message Detail
| #025
Mushroom Division Round 1 - Match 1 – (1)Mario vs. (8)Joanna Dark
Mario
Game/Series Known From: Super Mario
Extrapolated Rank in 2002: 6th (37.47%)
Extrapolated Rank in 2003: 5th (38.18%)
Extrapolated Rank in 2004: 6th (34.77%)
Seed in 2002: 1
Seed in 2003: 1
Seed in 2004: 2
Lost in 2002 to Link in the Finals
Lost in 2003 to Sephiroth in the Elite 8
Lost in 2004 to Crono in the Sweet 16
Mamma Mia! Look who’s kicking off the Contest again with a 1-seed. It’s Mario!
Joanna Dark
Game/Series Known From: Perfect Dark
Extrapolated Rank in 2002: N/A
Extrapolated Rank in 2003: N/A
Extrapolated Rank in 2004: N/A
Seed in 2002: N/A
Seed in 2003: N/A
Seed in 2004: N/A
Joanna? Now there’s someone I didn’t expect to see in here. Must be PDZ hype.
It’s good to be analyzing a Summer Contest bracket again. So good…
This match should play out a lot like Mario/Morrigan did, except with Joanna being a much weaker Morrigan...meaning the match shouldn’t play out a lot like it at all…meaning that my previous statement doesn’t make sense. Oh well.
Moltar’s Bracket Says: Mario will win.
Moltar’s Prediction is: Mario: 78% - Joanna: 22%
Ulti’s Analysis
In six contests, Nintendo has been the 1 seed in the first match six times. Mario continues the trend, and this year Joanna Dark is the fodder. Perfect Dark Zero may have had something to do with this, but Ngamer64 (the biggest Perfect Dark fan on the board) is no slouch in his own right when it comes to rallying some friends. And thankfully, we'll probably see the cel shaded hot Joanna instead of the short-haired idiot from the N64 title.
Not that the match is in question in the least, but Joanna could surprise everyone and land in the 20-25% range. Mario took on JC Denton of Deus Ex fame last year, and Denton managed 16.46%. You have to figure that a console FPS character from one of N64's most critically acclaimed games can do better than 16.46%, especially given recent Xbox exposure.
So what the hell, let's take JC's percentage and add 7% to it.
Ulti’s Prediction: Mario with 76.54%
Soul’s Analysis
What a better way to start off this contest with the mascot of videogames, Mario. Mario finally gets his deserving one seed again. It looks to be a great contest for this somewhat hefty plumber. He actually has a fair shot at winning it all! Well, enough about the future, let's get on with his first round match.
Joanna Dark is from the Perfect Dark games. I'm sure everyone has heard of the PD game for N64 or heard about the PD game for XBox, right? For those of us who are a fan of FPS games, Perfect Dark is one of those truly "wow" games that makes us happy to be fans of the genre. Of course, it wasn't Half Life or another PC FPS, but for a console shooter, it was among the best. The XBox version of Perfect Dark is very anticipated because of it's performance with the N64. Joanna is the main character of the series, in case you didn't know.
So, we kick off the tourny with a relatively close match, right? I mean, PD is a classic game. Joanna should be able to put up a fight, right? Well, let me remind you who exactly she is facing. Mario, the most known video game character of all time. Mario, who stars in classic hits like Super Mario Bros. 3, Super Mario World and Super Mario 64. Mario, who stars in Super Smash Brothers, Super Smash Brother Melee, Super Mario Kart, Mario Kart 64, Mario Golf 64, Mario Tennis, Mario Party 1-18, the list goes on. If there's one way to get your character known is to place him/her in as much spinoffs as possible. It seems like Nintendo mastered that art.
So, can Joanna, with her one classic hit, compare with Mario? Nah, seriously doubt it.
My prediction: Mario wins with 85.56% of the vote. This will hopefully please Heroic Mario.
Mario
Game/Series Known From: Super Mario
Extrapolated Rank in 2002: 6th (37.47%)
Extrapolated Rank in 2003: 5th (38.18%)
Extrapolated Rank in 2004: 6th (34.77%)
Seed in 2002: 1
Seed in 2003: 1
Seed in 2004: 2
Lost in 2002 to Link in the Finals
Lost in 2003 to Sephiroth in the Elite 8
Lost in 2004 to Crono in the Sweet 16
Mamma Mia! Look who’s kicking off the Contest again with a 1-seed. It’s Mario!
Joanna Dark
Game/Series Known From: Perfect Dark
Extrapolated Rank in 2002: N/A
Extrapolated Rank in 2003: N/A
Extrapolated Rank in 2004: N/A
Seed in 2002: N/A
Seed in 2003: N/A
Seed in 2004: N/A
Joanna? Now there’s someone I didn’t expect to see in here. Must be PDZ hype.
It’s good to be analyzing a Summer Contest bracket again. So good…
This match should play out a lot like Mario/Morrigan did, except with Joanna being a much weaker Morrigan...meaning the match shouldn’t play out a lot like it at all…meaning that my previous statement doesn’t make sense. Oh well.
Moltar’s Bracket Says: Mario will win.
Moltar’s Prediction is: Mario: 78% - Joanna: 22%
Ulti’s Analysis
In six contests, Nintendo has been the 1 seed in the first match six times. Mario continues the trend, and this year Joanna Dark is the fodder. Perfect Dark Zero may have had something to do with this, but Ngamer64 (the biggest Perfect Dark fan on the board) is no slouch in his own right when it comes to rallying some friends. And thankfully, we'll probably see the cel shaded hot Joanna instead of the short-haired idiot from the N64 title.
Not that the match is in question in the least, but Joanna could surprise everyone and land in the 20-25% range. Mario took on JC Denton of Deus Ex fame last year, and Denton managed 16.46%. You have to figure that a console FPS character from one of N64's most critically acclaimed games can do better than 16.46%, especially given recent Xbox exposure.
So what the hell, let's take JC's percentage and add 7% to it.
Ulti’s Prediction: Mario with 76.54%
Soul’s Analysis
What a better way to start off this contest with the mascot of videogames, Mario. Mario finally gets his deserving one seed again. It looks to be a great contest for this somewhat hefty plumber. He actually has a fair shot at winning it all! Well, enough about the future, let's get on with his first round match.
Joanna Dark is from the Perfect Dark games. I'm sure everyone has heard of the PD game for N64 or heard about the PD game for XBox, right? For those of us who are a fan of FPS games, Perfect Dark is one of those truly "wow" games that makes us happy to be fans of the genre. Of course, it wasn't Half Life or another PC FPS, but for a console shooter, it was among the best. The XBox version of Perfect Dark is very anticipated because of it's performance with the N64. Joanna is the main character of the series, in case you didn't know.
So, we kick off the tourny with a relatively close match, right? I mean, PD is a classic game. Joanna should be able to put up a fight, right? Well, let me remind you who exactly she is facing. Mario, the most known video game character of all time. Mario, who stars in classic hits like Super Mario Bros. 3, Super Mario World and Super Mario 64. Mario, who stars in Super Smash Brothers, Super Smash Brother Melee, Super Mario Kart, Mario Kart 64, Mario Golf 64, Mario Tennis, Mario Party 1-18, the list goes on. If there's one way to get your character known is to place him/her in as much spinoffs as possible. It seems like Nintendo mastered that art.
So, can Joanna, with her one classic hit, compare with Mario? Nah, seriously doubt it.
My prediction: Mario wins with 85.56% of the vote. This will hopefully please Heroic Mario.
From: Master Moltar
| Posted: 7/18/2005 8:17:42 PM | Message Detail
| #026
Outback’s Analysis
He's a friggin ICON!
Another season, another contest. And again, we start with a bang, but with the best bracket in recent contest history, who's complaining? I for one am very happy with the bracket, and await the beatdown that's coming in the first match.
Mario, 82.21, Joanna 17.79
Inviso’s Analysis
Well…once again...Mario is a one seed. And he’s against a hottie. I have seen Joanna Dark from the N64 game…and she was nowhere near as good looking as she is now, and I gotta applaud this pic. But anyway, on to the actual match. Mario is noble nine. He’s pretty much a lock for his division. But unlike previous contests…where he took on Servbot, a weak character from the Megaman series, Captain Olimar, a character from ANOTHER Nintendo game that is nowhere near as popular as the Mario series, and JC Denton, from another game that is relatively overlooked…he’s taking on Joanna. He’s taking on a female character, which is the main character of a game that gets a lot of praise not only on Gamefaqs, but also in the mainstream. It’s often regarded as the best FPS of all time alongside another Rare game…Goldeneye. Combine this with the fact that Mario’s popularity has been on the decline in recent years…with his lack of good games, and Joanna could perform well.
My Bracket: Mario Mario
My Vote: Joanna Dark
My Prediction: Mario Mario with 76.54%
Tnote’s Analysis
Mario has a documented history of first round blow-outs that are just not exactly as big as they should be. Actually, Mario has a documented history of beating a lot of opponents by not quite as much as he should. Some people equate this to some semblance of anti-voting, some people equate this to JC Denton vote stuffers, and everybody else really could care less about why Mario let Captain Olimar crack five-digits.
I personally never got a chance to play Perfect Dark, and I probably will not be touching any subsequent sequel or thirdquel Rare decides to release. That being said, Perfect Dark performed fairly admirably against an extremely under-seeded Symphony of the Night. Joanna should not be as strong in relation to her game as Alucard, but she still may be able to avoid a quadrupling.
Pick: Mario with 78.27%
Vlado’s Analysis
Not much to write here... It's clear Mario will win, even (or especially) if you're a complete n00b on GameFAQs. I'm very surprised Joanna actually made the contest... But there were even bigger surprises there (see Manny Calavera). Since it's her debut, I can only assume about how strong she will be. One could go on and say how she has the so-called TJF on her side and how Mario will also get anti-votes, but I doubt that'll do much... Well, Perfect Dark was one of the big N64 games and Perfect Dark Zero will be huge on the Xbox 360, but... "Will" is the keyword here. Hype alone could hardly give her a significant boost, especially knowing that Xbox is not big on GameFAQs. At least until then, Joanna is just your average fodder, though I believe she'll do a couple percent better than her fellow Rare character Conker.
Predicted percentage: Mario with 72.34%.
He's a friggin ICON!
Another season, another contest. And again, we start with a bang, but with the best bracket in recent contest history, who's complaining? I for one am very happy with the bracket, and await the beatdown that's coming in the first match.
Mario, 82.21, Joanna 17.79
Inviso’s Analysis
Well…once again...Mario is a one seed. And he’s against a hottie. I have seen Joanna Dark from the N64 game…and she was nowhere near as good looking as she is now, and I gotta applaud this pic. But anyway, on to the actual match. Mario is noble nine. He’s pretty much a lock for his division. But unlike previous contests…where he took on Servbot, a weak character from the Megaman series, Captain Olimar, a character from ANOTHER Nintendo game that is nowhere near as popular as the Mario series, and JC Denton, from another game that is relatively overlooked…he’s taking on Joanna. He’s taking on a female character, which is the main character of a game that gets a lot of praise not only on Gamefaqs, but also in the mainstream. It’s often regarded as the best FPS of all time alongside another Rare game…Goldeneye. Combine this with the fact that Mario’s popularity has been on the decline in recent years…with his lack of good games, and Joanna could perform well.
My Bracket: Mario Mario
My Vote: Joanna Dark
My Prediction: Mario Mario with 76.54%
Tnote’s Analysis
Mario has a documented history of first round blow-outs that are just not exactly as big as they should be. Actually, Mario has a documented history of beating a lot of opponents by not quite as much as he should. Some people equate this to some semblance of anti-voting, some people equate this to JC Denton vote stuffers, and everybody else really could care less about why Mario let Captain Olimar crack five-digits.
I personally never got a chance to play Perfect Dark, and I probably will not be touching any subsequent sequel or thirdquel Rare decides to release. That being said, Perfect Dark performed fairly admirably against an extremely under-seeded Symphony of the Night. Joanna should not be as strong in relation to her game as Alucard, but she still may be able to avoid a quadrupling.
Pick: Mario with 78.27%
Vlado’s Analysis
Not much to write here... It's clear Mario will win, even (or especially) if you're a complete n00b on GameFAQs. I'm very surprised Joanna actually made the contest... But there were even bigger surprises there (see Manny Calavera). Since it's her debut, I can only assume about how strong she will be. One could go on and say how she has the so-called TJF on her side and how Mario will also get anti-votes, but I doubt that'll do much... Well, Perfect Dark was one of the big N64 games and Perfect Dark Zero will be huge on the Xbox 360, but... "Will" is the keyword here. Hype alone could hardly give her a significant boost, especially knowing that Xbox is not big on GameFAQs. At least until then, Joanna is just your average fodder, though I believe she'll do a couple percent better than her fellow Rare character Conker.
Predicted percentage: Mario with 72.34%.
From: mr_BRIAN
| Posted: 7/18/2005 8:45:39 PM | Message Detail
| #027
Hey look, a poorly-disguised tag!
---
The King of all Cosmos' route to summer victory:
Round 1: (4) Tidus... LET ME DREAM :
---
The King of all Cosmos' route to summer victory:
Round 1: (4) Tidus... LET ME DREAM :
From: UltimaterializerX
| Posted: 7/18/2005 8:46:16 PM | Message Detail
| #028
Inviso, I love you.
~*ST*~
---
Winner of the Spring 2004 "Best. Game. Ever." Contest
"If my fate is to be destroyed... I must simply laugh!" -Magus
~*ST*~
---
Winner of the Spring 2004 "Best. Game. Ever." Contest
"If my fate is to be destroyed... I must simply laugh!" -Magus
From: smasherx
| Posted: 7/19/2005 3:35:20 AM | Message Detail
| #029
Im tagging this early. And just for the sake of twisted irony, I'm predicting the winners of this analysis contest:
Ulti: 15
Soul: 14
Vlado: 11
Moltar: 10
Invisio: 9
Outback: 4
Tnote: 4
Maybe I'll make an actual analysis for my prediction one day. Or maybe I'll tell you the truth that it's completely random.
Ulti: 15
Soul: 14
Vlado: 11
Moltar: 10
Invisio: 9
Outback: 4
Tnote: 4
Maybe I'll make an actual analysis for my prediction one day. Or maybe I'll tell you the truth that it's completely random.
From: DarkLink89
| Posted: 7/19/2005 10:03:29 AM | Message Detail
| #030
I'm tagging this
---
"For the next 15 years, just like the last 15, handheld gaming will be known by one name: Nintendo" - Reggie Fils-Aime
---
"For the next 15 years, just like the last 15, handheld gaming will be known by one name: Nintendo" - Reggie Fils-Aime
From: Master Moltar
| Posted: 7/19/2005 10:43:03 AM | Message Detail
| #031
Right now, it's looking like Outback is going to take today's match.
Nice performance by Mario by the way. Unless you want to think Joanna is just a bit stronger than Denton, I think it's safe to say that the Big M has increased a little since 2004.
You took out what I had in parenthesis, you bastard :(
>.>
And just for the sake of twisted irony, I'm predicting the winners of this analysis contest:
Nice predictions. Too bad it doesn't have me in first where I belong. ^_~
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
Mario vs. Joanna - Bracket: Mario - Vote: Mario (0/0)
Nice performance by Mario by the way. Unless you want to think Joanna is just a bit stronger than Denton, I think it's safe to say that the Big M has increased a little since 2004.
You took out what I had in parenthesis, you bastard :(
>.>
And just for the sake of twisted irony, I'm predicting the winners of this analysis contest:
Nice predictions. Too bad it doesn't have me in first where I belong. ^_~
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
Mario vs. Joanna - Bracket: Mario - Vote: Mario (0/0)
From: Master Moltar
| Posted: 7/19/2005 3:38:06 PM | Message Detail
| #032
Mushroom Division Round 1 - Match 2 – (4)Ness vs. (5)Carl Johnson
Ness
Game/Series Known From: Earthbound
Extrapolated Rank in 2002: N/A
Extrapolated Rank in 2003: 55th (15.44%)
Extrapolated Rank in 2004: 34th (19.14%)
Seed in 2002: N/A
Seed in 2003: 12
Seed in 2004: 6
Lost in 2003 to Bowser in Round 1
Lost in 2004 to Auron in Round 2
Ness is still weak as ever, and manages to worm his way back into the Contest, and again, he has a higher seed.
CJ
Game/Series Known From: Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
Extrapolated Rank in 2002: N/A
Extrapolated Rank in 2003: N/A
Extrapolated Rank in 2004: N/A
Seed in 2002: N/A
Seed in 2003: N/A
Seed in 2004: N/A
Another newbie steps up to the plate and tries to prove himself to us. This time it’s CJ from San Andreas.
Wow, here’s our second match of the Contest, and again, it’s trying to throw us off guard. In 2002, Morrigan upset Spyro. In 2003, Fox upset Pikachu. In 2004, Ganondorf didn’t upset Alucard since he was the higher seed, but it did throw a lot of people off. Only 63.02% of the brackets got it right. Now the tradition of the “It looks tough to predict but if you take some time and look at the match it’s actually pretty obvious” second matches continues with Ness vs. Carl Johnson.
Ness has a Baseball Bat! Carl has a Gun! Guns > Baseball Bats!
Well, let’s analyze this baby. Ness is from the hugely cult Earthbound. Ness is possibly the most popular cult character at GameFAQs. CJ on the other hand, is from the biggest game with the casuals right now, GTA:SA. Cults vs. Casuals, what a match! Polls at GameFAQs are decided by both, and I believe that the casuals will give CJ the victory.
“But Moltar!” You scream, “Isn’t that the same argument used for people who said Jak would beat Ness?” Well, CJ is in a entirely different league than Jak. Jak was weak. He game is weak. His game wasn’t Game of the Year at GameFAQs. San Andreas was.
Ness wears his hat backwards! CJ wears his hat to show his gang sign! Gangs > coolness!
So yeah, CJ isn’t going to be wiping any floors with his opponent. Ness will keep it somewhat close. He has a decent-sized fanbase, but I think Carl is going to be much stronger than Jak, and the casuals will silence the cults this time.
Ness is white! CJ is black! Bla- No, let’s not even go there.
Moltar’s Bracket Says: CJ will win.
Moltar’s Prediction is: Ness: 44% - CJ: 56%
Ulti’s Analysis
This match is deceptive in that it's a lot more interesting than it looks. At a first glance, one would assume that Carl has it in the bag due to the smash success of San Andreas even on GameFAQs, a site that is massively skewed toward hardcore gaming and a somewhat younger taste (ie, GameFAQs loves their good Nintendo games).
The catch is appeal. Ness has been in all of these contests since 2003 in some form, and the EarthBound fanbase will vote all things EB over anything else. Ness isn't strong in the least, but he has his following. And while I believe that CJ will win (and with relative ease in relation to the hype that the match has been getting), I don't think that CJ will be as strong as Vercetti. GameFAQs is very.... white, to say the least, and I doubt that CJ will have the casual appeal of an Italian mobster. I could be wrong, but who knows. Either way, I believe that CJ will be weaker than Vercetti, but beat Ness in a close match. There is a little wiggle room in there, and the fact that people know who CJ is should push him over the top in what could be a surprisingly close match.
Ulti’s Prediction: CJ with 52.34%
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
Mario vs. Joanna - Bracket: Mario - Vote: Mario (0/0)
Ness
Game/Series Known From: Earthbound
Extrapolated Rank in 2002: N/A
Extrapolated Rank in 2003: 55th (15.44%)
Extrapolated Rank in 2004: 34th (19.14%)
Seed in 2002: N/A
Seed in 2003: 12
Seed in 2004: 6
Lost in 2003 to Bowser in Round 1
Lost in 2004 to Auron in Round 2
Ness is still weak as ever, and manages to worm his way back into the Contest, and again, he has a higher seed.
CJ
Game/Series Known From: Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
Extrapolated Rank in 2002: N/A
Extrapolated Rank in 2003: N/A
Extrapolated Rank in 2004: N/A
Seed in 2002: N/A
Seed in 2003: N/A
Seed in 2004: N/A
Another newbie steps up to the plate and tries to prove himself to us. This time it’s CJ from San Andreas.
Wow, here’s our second match of the Contest, and again, it’s trying to throw us off guard. In 2002, Morrigan upset Spyro. In 2003, Fox upset Pikachu. In 2004, Ganondorf didn’t upset Alucard since he was the higher seed, but it did throw a lot of people off. Only 63.02% of the brackets got it right. Now the tradition of the “It looks tough to predict but if you take some time and look at the match it’s actually pretty obvious” second matches continues with Ness vs. Carl Johnson.
Ness has a Baseball Bat! Carl has a Gun! Guns > Baseball Bats!
Well, let’s analyze this baby. Ness is from the hugely cult Earthbound. Ness is possibly the most popular cult character at GameFAQs. CJ on the other hand, is from the biggest game with the casuals right now, GTA:SA. Cults vs. Casuals, what a match! Polls at GameFAQs are decided by both, and I believe that the casuals will give CJ the victory.
“But Moltar!” You scream, “Isn’t that the same argument used for people who said Jak would beat Ness?” Well, CJ is in a entirely different league than Jak. Jak was weak. He game is weak. His game wasn’t Game of the Year at GameFAQs. San Andreas was.
Ness wears his hat backwards! CJ wears his hat to show his gang sign! Gangs > coolness!
So yeah, CJ isn’t going to be wiping any floors with his opponent. Ness will keep it somewhat close. He has a decent-sized fanbase, but I think Carl is going to be much stronger than Jak, and the casuals will silence the cults this time.
Ness is white! CJ is black! Bla- No, let’s not even go there.
Moltar’s Bracket Says: CJ will win.
Moltar’s Prediction is: Ness: 44% - CJ: 56%
Ulti’s Analysis
This match is deceptive in that it's a lot more interesting than it looks. At a first glance, one would assume that Carl has it in the bag due to the smash success of San Andreas even on GameFAQs, a site that is massively skewed toward hardcore gaming and a somewhat younger taste (ie, GameFAQs loves their good Nintendo games).
The catch is appeal. Ness has been in all of these contests since 2003 in some form, and the EarthBound fanbase will vote all things EB over anything else. Ness isn't strong in the least, but he has his following. And while I believe that CJ will win (and with relative ease in relation to the hype that the match has been getting), I don't think that CJ will be as strong as Vercetti. GameFAQs is very.... white, to say the least, and I doubt that CJ will have the casual appeal of an Italian mobster. I could be wrong, but who knows. Either way, I believe that CJ will be weaker than Vercetti, but beat Ness in a close match. There is a little wiggle room in there, and the fact that people know who CJ is should push him over the top in what could be a surprisingly close match.
Ulti’s Prediction: CJ with 52.34%
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
Mario vs. Joanna - Bracket: Mario - Vote: Mario (0/0)
From: Master Moltar
| Posted: 7/19/2005 3:38:26 PM | Message Detail
| #033
Soul’s Analysis
Well, what do we have here? Our first match that could go either way? Hmm... interesting.
Ness is from the cult classic Earthbound for the Super Nintendo. He's also in the SSB series. CJ is from GTA: San Andreas, a very popular game among the casuals.
Now, you say this match is going to be close? Among all the evidence I have stating otherwise, I'll just tell you one thing. Popular > Cult. kthx.
But if you still don't believe me after all that huge evidence, let me ask you a question. How many of you actually heard of Earthbound other then on GameFAQs? How many of you seen the commercials for San Andreas? You know, the one with "Welcome to the Jungle" playing in it. Come on, don't lie to me, of course you seen it at least once. Hell, I'm still seeing them regularly on TV, and I only watch 2 hours of TV per day, tops. So let me repeat this: Popularity > Cult.
More proof is that Tommy Vercetti places 11 spots higher then Ness. CJ is expected to be more powerful than Vercetti. After putting two and two together, things are going to look pretty messy for Ness.
My prediction: CJ wins with 62.23% of the vote. Close? I think not. *Goes off to listen to some Guns N' Roses*
Outback’s Analysis
A gun against a baseball bat. Who wins?
Another contest, another debated 2nd match. This time we have GTA: SA posterboy Carl Johnson against Earthbound lead Ness. To the outside bracketmaker, this match looks pretty obvious. CJ is from GTA, one of the most, if not the most, mainstream franchises in all of gaming, against Ness, an obscure character from a love/hate SNES RPG. And honestly, they're not too far off. Sure, GTA is relatively weak in these contests; Tommy Vercetti has never exactly been a power, but Ness only managed 56% against Jak, who while having starred in games on the PS2, has never reached the popularity that the GTA series has. Is 6% that much of a bridge for CJ to gap? I think not, and he'll do more than 6% better than Jak.
CJ, 56.42, Ness 43.58
Inviso’s Analysis
Ness won his first match ever…Earthbound’s first match ever…last summer, against Jak. Let’s give him a big hand…that he doesn’t have to beat at the end of Classic Mode. Well…that victory proved one thing. Ness is a decent character? Hell no. It proved that PS2 platformers get **** for respect on this site. It proved that Jak sucks. That being said…we have Carl Johnson, from Gamefaqs’ game of the year, Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas. Now, Ness may have a lot of Nintendo votes from SSB and SSB: M…but even with all of that…he’s still little more than a cult character. Tommy Vercetti, from GTA: Vice City, managed to beat Donkey Kong, who is much more popular and well known than Ness, so I can’t see Carl having any trouble at all.
My Bracket: Carl Johnson
My Vote: Carl Johnson
My Prediction: Carl Johnson with 64.88%
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
Mario vs. Joanna - Bracket: Mario - Vote: Mario (0/0)
Well, what do we have here? Our first match that could go either way? Hmm... interesting.
Ness is from the cult classic Earthbound for the Super Nintendo. He's also in the SSB series. CJ is from GTA: San Andreas, a very popular game among the casuals.
Now, you say this match is going to be close? Among all the evidence I have stating otherwise, I'll just tell you one thing. Popular > Cult. kthx.
But if you still don't believe me after all that huge evidence, let me ask you a question. How many of you actually heard of Earthbound other then on GameFAQs? How many of you seen the commercials for San Andreas? You know, the one with "Welcome to the Jungle" playing in it. Come on, don't lie to me, of course you seen it at least once. Hell, I'm still seeing them regularly on TV, and I only watch 2 hours of TV per day, tops. So let me repeat this: Popularity > Cult.
More proof is that Tommy Vercetti places 11 spots higher then Ness. CJ is expected to be more powerful than Vercetti. After putting two and two together, things are going to look pretty messy for Ness.
My prediction: CJ wins with 62.23% of the vote. Close? I think not. *Goes off to listen to some Guns N' Roses*
Outback’s Analysis
A gun against a baseball bat. Who wins?
Another contest, another debated 2nd match. This time we have GTA: SA posterboy Carl Johnson against Earthbound lead Ness. To the outside bracketmaker, this match looks pretty obvious. CJ is from GTA, one of the most, if not the most, mainstream franchises in all of gaming, against Ness, an obscure character from a love/hate SNES RPG. And honestly, they're not too far off. Sure, GTA is relatively weak in these contests; Tommy Vercetti has never exactly been a power, but Ness only managed 56% against Jak, who while having starred in games on the PS2, has never reached the popularity that the GTA series has. Is 6% that much of a bridge for CJ to gap? I think not, and he'll do more than 6% better than Jak.
CJ, 56.42, Ness 43.58
Inviso’s Analysis
Ness won his first match ever…Earthbound’s first match ever…last summer, against Jak. Let’s give him a big hand…that he doesn’t have to beat at the end of Classic Mode. Well…that victory proved one thing. Ness is a decent character? Hell no. It proved that PS2 platformers get **** for respect on this site. It proved that Jak sucks. That being said…we have Carl Johnson, from Gamefaqs’ game of the year, Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas. Now, Ness may have a lot of Nintendo votes from SSB and SSB: M…but even with all of that…he’s still little more than a cult character. Tommy Vercetti, from GTA: Vice City, managed to beat Donkey Kong, who is much more popular and well known than Ness, so I can’t see Carl having any trouble at all.
My Bracket: Carl Johnson
My Vote: Carl Johnson
My Prediction: Carl Johnson with 64.88%
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
Mario vs. Joanna - Bracket: Mario - Vote: Mario (0/0)
From: Master Moltar
| Posted: 7/19/2005 3:39:26 PM | Message Detail
| #034
Tnote’s Analysis
This is the match that I am really anxious to see, and fortunately, I will know within two days whether or not I will have a chance in this contest. I have spent a lot of time analyzing this match-up from both a mathematical and a common sensical direction. The common sense in me says that Ness just cannot compete with something as vast and consuming as Grand Theft Auto. The mathematics, however, have left me with a slightly different outlook.
I feel that 2k3 Vercetti would beat 2k5 CJ around 60/40. I feel this way for numerous reasons which are not terribly relevant in this analysis. Using a non SFFed Ness, Vercetti is expected to beat him with around 62%. This leaves CJ with a couple percentage points on Ness, which I think can be made up from a couple different sources. I think the SSB:M blitz will only help Ness increase his popularity as time goes along. Additionally, I think there is a race factor that could hurt CJ. Tenpenny really should not have lost that bad to Liquid, especially given he is voiced by freakin’ Samuel L. Jackson. Enough people have played against Tenpenny, as evidenced by the GTA:SA domination of the FAQs. And while I know FAQ popularity does not equal contest success, it sure as hell should equate at least 25% on Liquid Snake. All things considered, I see this as a great place to pick an upset, and I am going to do just that.
Pick: Ness with 50.83%
Vlado’s Analysis
The second day of the tournament should give us a slightly more exciting match. However, I don't see it ruining any actually serious brackets. Ness proved to be a weakling in his two appearences in the contest, getting blown out by Bowser in 2003 and doing just a bit better against Auron in 2004, where he managed to avoid getting doubled. However, it's admirable how loyal the Earthbound fans are, not only helping him get in, but also earning him a respectable seed. Anyway, a cult fanbase is far from enough to get you wins against opponents that don't totally suck in the contest. It's obvious that Earthbound is far from something to be noticed on GameFAQs and Ness can mostly thank SSBM, not his original game, for his only win so far, last year against Jak. It is likely to also remain his only win, at least until he faces another fodder of Jak's caliber. Earthbound proved to be unbelievably weak with its loss against Doom in the spring of 2004, despite being the higher seed. And Giygas did not do much more this Spring than to earn the nickname "Menstrual Blood" thanks to his picture and then get blown out by Ganondorf. Luckily for him, Tenpenny managed to do even worse and occupied the last place. Bottom line, Ness is weak and has absolutely no reason to have improved since last year.
Let's look at his opponent. Carl is the main character of GTA: SA, which has occupied the top spot of the Top 10 FAQ pages for quite a while now. However, judging by Tenpenny's aforementioned craptacular performance, we shouldn't be fooled about CJ's power. He'll naturally be much stronger than Tenpenny, but still not strong enough to stand any chance against Mario. I expect him to be just above Tommy Vercetti's 2004 level, which would be more than enough to easily take care of Ness.
Predicted percentage: Carl Johnson with 62.36%
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
Mario vs. Joanna - Bracket: Mario - Vote: Mario (0/0)
This is the match that I am really anxious to see, and fortunately, I will know within two days whether or not I will have a chance in this contest. I have spent a lot of time analyzing this match-up from both a mathematical and a common sensical direction. The common sense in me says that Ness just cannot compete with something as vast and consuming as Grand Theft Auto. The mathematics, however, have left me with a slightly different outlook.
I feel that 2k3 Vercetti would beat 2k5 CJ around 60/40. I feel this way for numerous reasons which are not terribly relevant in this analysis. Using a non SFFed Ness, Vercetti is expected to beat him with around 62%. This leaves CJ with a couple percentage points on Ness, which I think can be made up from a couple different sources. I think the SSB:M blitz will only help Ness increase his popularity as time goes along. Additionally, I think there is a race factor that could hurt CJ. Tenpenny really should not have lost that bad to Liquid, especially given he is voiced by freakin’ Samuel L. Jackson. Enough people have played against Tenpenny, as evidenced by the GTA:SA domination of the FAQs. And while I know FAQ popularity does not equal contest success, it sure as hell should equate at least 25% on Liquid Snake. All things considered, I see this as a great place to pick an upset, and I am going to do just that.
Pick: Ness with 50.83%
Vlado’s Analysis
The second day of the tournament should give us a slightly more exciting match. However, I don't see it ruining any actually serious brackets. Ness proved to be a weakling in his two appearences in the contest, getting blown out by Bowser in 2003 and doing just a bit better against Auron in 2004, where he managed to avoid getting doubled. However, it's admirable how loyal the Earthbound fans are, not only helping him get in, but also earning him a respectable seed. Anyway, a cult fanbase is far from enough to get you wins against opponents that don't totally suck in the contest. It's obvious that Earthbound is far from something to be noticed on GameFAQs and Ness can mostly thank SSBM, not his original game, for his only win so far, last year against Jak. It is likely to also remain his only win, at least until he faces another fodder of Jak's caliber. Earthbound proved to be unbelievably weak with its loss against Doom in the spring of 2004, despite being the higher seed. And Giygas did not do much more this Spring than to earn the nickname "Menstrual Blood" thanks to his picture and then get blown out by Ganondorf. Luckily for him, Tenpenny managed to do even worse and occupied the last place. Bottom line, Ness is weak and has absolutely no reason to have improved since last year.
Let's look at his opponent. Carl is the main character of GTA: SA, which has occupied the top spot of the Top 10 FAQ pages for quite a while now. However, judging by Tenpenny's aforementioned craptacular performance, we shouldn't be fooled about CJ's power. He'll naturally be much stronger than Tenpenny, but still not strong enough to stand any chance against Mario. I expect him to be just above Tommy Vercetti's 2004 level, which would be more than enough to easily take care of Ness.
Predicted percentage: Carl Johnson with 62.36%
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
Mario vs. Joanna - Bracket: Mario - Vote: Mario (0/0)
From: Adept_Of_Aiur
| Posted: 7/19/2005 3:48:05 PM | Message Detail
| #035
This is the match that I am really anxious to see, and fortunately,
I will know within two days whether or not I will have a chance in this
contest.
Missing a one point match isn't going to lose anyone the contest.
---
"Heil Dweebenheimer!"
MasterMage119
Missing a one point match isn't going to lose anyone the contest.
---
"Heil Dweebenheimer!"
MasterMage119
From: Inviso
| Posted: 7/19/2005 5:34:52 PM | Message Detail
| #036
Just wondering why you'd equate the NEW GTA character...to the OLD GTA character...2 years ago.
---
"Nobody knows the trouble I've seen. Nobody knows but Jesus."-Grif
"Shut the hell up Grif!"-Church
---
"Nobody knows the trouble I've seen. Nobody knows but Jesus."-Grif
"Shut the hell up Grif!"-Church
From: Heroic Viktor
| Posted: 7/19/2005 5:42:37 PM | Message Detail
| #037
Assuming that was directed to me, I did 2k3 Tommy on 2k5 CJ because 2k3
Tommy was his most powerful year, as it was his game's release year.
GTA is not a series I view as one where characters's popularity ages
well, as I expect Tommy to be weaker this year than he was last year,
just as I viewed him to be weaker last year than he was the year
before. Basically, what I was saying is Tommy at the height of his
popularity would beat CJ at the height of his popularity at least
60/40, with the difference resulting from a myriad of reasons I am way
too lazy to explain. If Ness gets hammered tomorrow, I clearly was
wrong about my views, but if CJ does not crack 55%, it would be a very
difficult sell to expect CJ to be more popular than Vercetti. Really,
anything under 60% leans in the favor of Vercetti>CJ.
---
RIP: Tnote827 - 4/4/2005
Sp2k5 - 77/80 (stupid Master Hand)
---
RIP: Tnote827 - 4/4/2005
Sp2k5 - 77/80 (stupid Master Hand)
From: Cokes11
| Posted: 7/19/2005 5:46:59 PM | Message Detail
| #038
Inviso, I'm wondering why you (and others) are calling GTA:SA GotY, when it came out last October. Sure, it just came out on XBOX and PC, but I'd wager 75% (perhaps more) of its final sales will be from PS2.
~~~
Trivia XV: Dragostea Din Tei
http://www.audioscrobbler.com/user/cokes311/
~~~
Trivia XV: Dragostea Din Tei
http://www.audioscrobbler.com/user/cokes311/
From: XxSoulxX
| Posted: 7/19/2005 6:01:22 PM | Message Detail
| #039
It was ranked GotY last year on GameFAQS.
---
"ertyu is actually a language. For example, 'dum' is ertyunese for 'godly'." - Topaz Kitsune
*Waiting for Guru winner's sig*
---
"ertyu is actually a language. For example, 'dum' is ertyunese for 'godly'." - Topaz Kitsune
*Waiting for Guru winner's sig*
From: dowolf
| Posted: 7/19/2005 10:35:19 PM | Message Detail
| #040
Tag
---
I shave the goats until they have 100 sides, paint each of the 100 sides with a number, and drop them off a cliff; they're like die, except much funnier-TheRNG
---
I shave the goats until they have 100 sides, paint each of the 100 sides with a number, and drop them off a cliff; they're like die, except much funnier-TheRNG
From: Ngamer64
| Posted: 7/19/2005 10:45:23 PM | Message Detail
| #041
I'm going to do an impression of me tagging this topic!
---
the-elite.net congratulates yoblazer, winner of the Spring '05 Guru Contest!
Contest Archives: http://thengamer.com/gamefaqs/
---
the-elite.net congratulates yoblazer, winner of the Spring '05 Guru Contest!
Contest Archives: http://thengamer.com/gamefaqs/
From: JonesSodaMaster 2
| Posted: 7/19/2005 10:45:46 PM | Message Detail
| #042
[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]
From: M120T
| Posted: 7/19/2005 11:01:14 PM | Message Detail
| #043
tag
---
This is just here so my post looks normal.
---
This is just here so my post looks normal.
From: DBZFIGHTERS
| Posted: 7/20/2005 12:44:53 AM | Message Detail
| #044
I think it's obvious Gordan Freeman would win the contest.
---
llll \|/ llll GO CANADA GO
llll ¯|¯ llll Die hard Cubs, Pistons, Patriot and Maple Leaf fan.
---
llll \|/ llll GO CANADA GO
llll ¯|¯ llll Die hard Cubs, Pistons, Patriot and Maple Leaf fan.
From: HarryCaray
| Posted: 7/20/2005 12:46:08 AM | Message Detail
| #045
Hey! I think I already analyzed the whole thing. You can check, it was a rush!
From: DarkLink89
| Posted: 7/20/2005 9:50:09 AM | Message Detail
| #046
Well, there goes my perfect bracket
---
"For the next 15 years, just like the last 15, handheld gaming will be known by one name: Nintendo" - Reggie Fils-Aime
---
"For the next 15 years, just like the last 15, handheld gaming will be known by one name: Nintendo" - Reggie Fils-Aime
From: Heroic Viktor
| Posted: 7/20/2005 9:53:56 AM | Message Detail
| #047
Not mine... =)
---
RIP: Tnote827 - 4/4/2005
Sp2k5 - 77/80 (stupid Master Hand)
---
RIP: Tnote827 - 4/4/2005
Sp2k5 - 77/80 (stupid Master Hand)
From: Master Moltar
| Posted: 7/20/2005 11:22:55 AM | Message Detail
| #048
[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]
From: Master Moltar
| Posted: 7/20/2005 11:26:56 AM | Message Detail
| #049
Mario...................80.9% 80157
Joanna Dark.........19.1% 18925
TOTAL VOTES................99082
96.53% of the brackets called this match correctly.
Well, great vote totals for the first match. It seems that this might be 2003 all over again vote-wise, which is excellent news. In the first match of the Contest, Mario whooped Joanna in a JC Denon-like manner. It is looking likely that Mario might have boosted, unless you think JC and Joanna are that close to each other.
Today, Ness is surprising many again. Last year, he surprised against Jak, this year against CJ. Right now, Ness has 54% of the vote and is gaining. Seems we have the first huge board upset already. Looks like this Contest is looking to be as unpredictible as we wanted.
Also, congrats to Inviso! Both her brackets made it on the leaderboard. Hopefully we might see Tnote as well, after calling this match correctly.
CLOSEST PREDICTIONS
Outback - 1
Moltar - 0
Ulti - 0
Soul - 0
Inviso - 0
Tnote - 0
Vlado - 0
The match ends between Tnote and Outback's predictions, but Outback is a little closer. Nice job on the first point!
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
Ness vs. CJ - Bracket: CJ - Vote: Ness (1/1)
Joanna Dark.........19.1% 18925
TOTAL VOTES................99082
96.53% of the brackets called this match correctly.
Well, great vote totals for the first match. It seems that this might be 2003 all over again vote-wise, which is excellent news. In the first match of the Contest, Mario whooped Joanna in a JC Denon-like manner. It is looking likely that Mario might have boosted, unless you think JC and Joanna are that close to each other.
Today, Ness is surprising many again. Last year, he surprised against Jak, this year against CJ. Right now, Ness has 54% of the vote and is gaining. Seems we have the first huge board upset already. Looks like this Contest is looking to be as unpredictible as we wanted.
Also, congrats to Inviso! Both her brackets made it on the leaderboard. Hopefully we might see Tnote as well, after calling this match correctly.
CLOSEST PREDICTIONS
Outback - 1
Moltar - 0
Ulti - 0
Soul - 0
Inviso - 0
Tnote - 0
Vlado - 0
The match ends between Tnote and Outback's predictions, but Outback is a little closer. Nice job on the first point!
---
Moltar's Comics - http://www.stripcreator.com/comics/Moltar
Ness vs. CJ - Bracket: CJ - Vote: Ness (1/1)
From: Infamus
| Posted: 7/20/2005 11:34:37 AM | Message Detail
| #050
tag
---
I had everythign set up right but when I fell off the chair I just hung there by my neck... I ended up getting bored - DiabloTerrorGF
---
I had everythign set up right but when I fell off the chair I just hung there by my neck... I ended up getting bored - DiabloTerrorGF
Quick Reply